AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY
of James Joyce's
Joyce reportedly boasted that Ulysses would keep the professors busy, and indeed it has occupied the bulk of articles pertaining to his work. Dubliners is often seen as a step to that great work, and its stories are often picked over for evidence of their influence on Ulysses. However, a number of tales in this collection have taken a critical life of their own. "The Dead," most obviously, attracts considerable attention, and "The Sisters" has also started to become regarded more seriously by the scholars. "Araby" has also been the loci of a fair amount of scholarship. It has become the standard secondary school Joyce reading, and it has become so frequently anthologized that it is a staple of introductory English Literature classes.
Criticism of "Araby" began in earnest in the early 1960s, largely buoyed by an article by Harry Stone that uncovered the dense symbolism undergirding the story. Since then, criticism of "Araby" seems to fall into three unique threads: First, following Stones precedent, is the Symbolic Thread, which seeks to uncover allusions to other authors, the hidden meaning behind objects in the text, or view its plot as an archetype of some sort. Secondly is the Theoretical Thread, which has attempted to apply contemporary literary criticism to the tale. Despite the dominance of post-modern criticism in the modern academy, Theorists have not taken much to the tale. Finally, the Pedagogical Thread, which views "Araby" as an ideal story which can be used either as a teaching tool or as a testing ground for theoretical approaches. Although this third group rarely illuminates a reading of "Araby," it illustrates a universality about the story that makes it a perfect example of the short story form. Through these three approaches, one may best view a history of "Araby" criticism.
Harry Stone published "'Araby and the Writings of James Joyce" in The Antioch Review in 1965. It is typical of Joyce criticism at the time in that it reads "Araby" through the later books, illustrating the elements that would later shape them. Stone claims that the story is "a portrait of the artist as a young boy" (376), arguing for an autobiographical basis to the story. However, Stones illumination of the stories symbolism made it a central article to the study of the story (the bulk of "Araby" articles site Stone). After locating rather basic allusions to Yeats and DeQuincy, his look at Joyces use of Mangan arguably begins the Symbolic Thread of criticism. Noting that "Mangan is an important name," Stone notes that the poet James Clarence Mangan strongly influenced Joyce. In "Araby," "Mangan" is the name both of the boys friend and, of course, his idealized sister. Stone suggests that the poem "Dark Rosaleen" is central to the story, stating that "Mangans poem contains the same blend of physical love and religious adoration that Joyce makes the boy show for Mangans sister" (387). The word Mangan, then, brings to mind a host of allusions: Ireland itself, poetry, "Dark Rosaleen," all of which play a role in discerning the meaning of "Araby." The storys importance, for Stone and others that follow, lies in its symbolic details.
It is unsurprising, then, that a minor spate of articles would illuminate various intricacies of Joyces text. In addition to reading Mangan, Stone touches upon, among other things, the symbolism of "blind," the word "Araby," the florin, vigils in the tale, and so one. It is not a particularly well-written articleit strays from its central point of relating "Araby" to Joyces later work (apRoberts is correct in repeatedly criticizing it for not having a thesis)but it posits the story as a tale brimming with symbolism through which the story is infinitely illuminated. The journal Explicator was a natural locus for scholars isolating the importance of details. Its pages hosted a brief exchange between William Going and Stanley Friedman on the poem featured in the story, "The Arabs Farewell to its Steed"; a very slight note on the "sixpenny entrance" from William Burto; a note on an allusion to St. Tarsicus, and several other brief bits. While rarely straying from the sort of insight that a reasonably bright student would make, these notes continue to illustrate the impulse to uncover symbolism that buttresses much Joyce criticism.
The symbolic approach had a vocal critic from the start in Robert apRoberts. "Araby and the Palimpsest of Criticism" also received publication in The Antioch Review in 1967, and it directly responds to Stones article. However, apRoberts concerns seem to be less with Stone than the limits of criticism in general. He begins strongly by revealing how an overzealous Symbolist can overstretch his bounds and reveal an incorrect point: Stone argued that the dead priest was greedy and immoral, symbolizing the decaying church. His evidence is the statement that he donated "all his money" after he died (a priest, after all, shouldnt have much money) and that his reading materials included The Devout Communicant, an anti-Catholic work by Abednego Seller. ApRoberts astutely notes that there is no textual authority for the priests greed. A secular priest can own property, and simply because Joyce doesnt mention that the priest is charitable doesnt mean hes necessarily uncharitable. But the final blow is apRoberts's argument that the Devout Communicant in the story was probably a very popular Catholic work by Pacificus Baker that was quite standard in Ireland (unlike Sellers, which, prodders note, he couldnt find anywhere in Ireland). Joyces biography proves that he would be familiar with Bakers work but not necessarily Sellers. ApRoberts continues by dismantling many of the symbolic reading Stone created, including all of the above mentioned.
While apRoberts's reading is certainly the stronger of the two, he himself cannot escape the grasp of the symbolic. He gives, for instance, a fine reading of the bicycle pump (an item that has generated much criticism) as "a symbol of the British commercial materialism which has corrupted Irish Catholicism" (476). Some of his suggestions may seem naďve to a generation weaned on post-structuralism. For instance, part of his argument against Stones interpretation of the florin reads:
the reason Joyce chose to have the boy clutch the florin is that he did not choose to have him clutch something else. What reader, no matter how attentive, would call to mind the history of the florin, even if he knew it, on the strength of its single mention in [a] sentence
Of course, any number of cultural materialists, Marxists, and reader-response critics would find this statement problematic, and indeed it seems extreme to impose limits on this sort of reading, which is certainly legitimate for certain purposes. One gets the impression that one could synthesize Stones symbolic meandering and apRoberts's rational formalism into an even stronger reading. Still, the strength of apRoberts's piece lies in its advocacy of intelligently read symbolism: "[I]f we consider the symbol-making power of the mind, anything may become symbolic for a reader," he notes. "[D]etails give verisimilitude and . some may take on symbolic significance in the light of the central idea of the story" (485). Though applied to "Araby," his advice should have strong resonance elsewhere.
Equally important, however, is apRobertss assertion that Stone errs in thinking that "Araby" must be read in light of Joyces later works. ApRoberts accuses Stone of using "Araby" as a "free-association fantasy" rather than a unique story in itself. Indeed, very little later criticism of "Araby" seeks to relate it to Ulysses or Finnegans Wake (Frank Turajs slight "Araby and Portrait: Stages of Pagan Conversion" is the notable exception), but, more fruitfully, it is compared to other Dubliners tales, as David W. Robinson, Earl Ingersoll, and Edward Cronin do in their more theoretical-based approaches, discussed later. apRoberts's article, in summary, is central to a symbolic reading of "Araby."
Later controversies in the symbolic approach focus on the structure of the plot and its possible allusion to various legends. Ben Collins, writing around the time of the Stone/apRoberts debate, argues that the text is governed by "extended similes," which are comparisons that "affect the total meaning of the work" (85). Collins is noteworthy for his attempts to guide Symbolist readings into the plot structure, but he fails to reach a conclusion. More modestly and more successfully Stephen Doloffs recent articles briefly but powerfully make plot connections with Paradise Lost, Rousseaus Confessions, and the life of Ignatious Loyola. Jerome Mandel wrote a notable article on the storys relation to medieval romance, and John Freimarck wrote an equally illuminating article on the Grail motifs and their relationship to the plot.
Indeed, symbolic criticism of Joyce continues today, even if recent articles have a slightly more theoretical bent than, say, the earlier Explicator notes. For instance, Judith Barisonzis "Who Eats Pigs Cheeks?" updates Florence Walzls note on the matter by approaching it in the Marxist/Historicist vein and discussion the class connotations of those in Joyces day who ate pigs' cheeks. Even an Explicator note like John Hartys alludes to the popular deconstructive idea of meaning existing in the margins, as he notes that fibs lead Joycean character towards epiphanies.
Several articles still follow Stones example in rooting the storys symbols in history, notably Donald Torchiana, which wonderfully gives copious historical background for the real Araby fair, but doesnt apply much to a reading of the story. Finally, Brugaletta and Haydens 1978 article "The Motivation for Anguish in Joyces Araby" begs for a response from apRoberts, being the same sort of "free-association fantasy" for which he chides Stone. The authors argue that Mangans sister was only a figment of the boys imagination, and they offer some slight discrepancies in the text, as well as events from other stories, as evidence. Despite apRobertss arguments, the search for symbolic meanings in "Araby" continues, in the above and other various forms.
Post-modernist theorists have not had a Stone/apRoberts argument over "Araby"; indeed, they seem to have only contributed the most basic of readings to the story. Indeed, one of the better theoretical writing on the story relates, in part, to some symbolism in the story. David Robinsons 1987 "The Narration of Reading in Joyces The Sisters, An Encounter, and Araby" utilizes a reader-response theory similar to that devised by Stanley Fish in Surprised By Sin: Robinson argues that the protagonists failure to interpret the signs of his impending failure are parallel to the readers failure to completely grasp the symbolism of the tale. This reading seems to compliment Collinss "Extended Simile" by bringing in that Fishian "flawed reader" component that would have well served that article.
For the most part, however, the limited range of post-modern analysis of "Araby" concentrates on Lacanian analysis. Garry Leonards "The Question and the Quest" retells the story from the point of view of Mangans Sister (and indeed, his article is currently the closest we have to a sustained feminist reading of this story). He notes early on, "If she is not the protagonist of the story, can she be seen as the contagonist whose powerful absence makes the boys presence in his own narrative possible?", thus setting the theoretical basis for the entire article. Slipping easily into the lexicon of Lacan, Leonard argues that "the subject of Araby is the desire of Mangans sister in the sense that her function in the boys narration as absence and lack is what permits his subjectivity" (460). He then takes us through the Lacanian realms of the Real, Symbolic, and Other while positing Mangans sister as "The Woman"which is, in Lacan, "a woman who appears to the masculine subject as feminine" (461). He then takes us through the story as Mangans sister "experiments with her ability to direct the boys gaze" by turning her bracelet (463); as her story is suppressed by the boy so he can tell his story (464); and finally as "the unspeakable dictates what gets spoken in a Maypole dance around the nonexistent phallus" (474). In short, Leonard touches on all the acceptable buzzwords of Lacanian theory, offering a kind of checklist reading of the story. For a Lacanian analysis, this is fairly lucid, and it approaches the text in much the same way as Harry Stone. Instead of looking for symbolic meaning, however, Leonard searches for a Lacanian paradigm.
In another Lacanian take, Earl Ingersoll finds the "absence" in the priest rather than Mangans sister. He argues that the priest is represented by nothing but his books, and this foregrounds the boys "immersion in textuality" (45). Building on Leonards article, Ingersoll shows how the storys final sentence is also the boys immersion in "the Real." This is not a new reading of the storymany commentator allude to the disillusionment in that sentencebut Ingersoll dresses it in theoretical clothes by applying post-modern language to an already acknowledged approach to the story.
As noted above, there are theoretical elements in some symbolic readings of "Araby," but for the most part, this area has not been sufficiently exploited. There are no strong historicist readings, even though people like Torchiana have researched the background, and there have been no strong feminist approaches either. There are books on Dubliners with these theoretical bents, but, considering the many possibilities "Araby" offers for insightful criticism, there is still work needed to be done. One wonders if the storys popular appeal has kept it from further theoretical analysis. Indeed, many of the approaches taken by the authors in the pedagogue group deal with post-modern criticism, but the story is used to illuminate the theory, not vice versa.
As mentioned before, "Araby" has become a standard text for introducing students to short fiction. The first major critics to deal with "Araby" were Cleaneth Brooks and Robert Penn Warren in their 1943 book Understanding Fiction. This brief section isolates many of the ideas that later critics would expand uponromantic disillusionment, religious references, the difference between the male narrator and the boy protagonist, and so forth. Of course, their objective with Understanding Fiction was teaching readers how to explicate a story. Neither critic has their full critical powers engaged; indeed, they see the value in using "Araby" as a teaching tool. Of course, "Araby" appears in many textbooks, illustrating its value as an introduction to fiction. Susan Robbinss article "Anguish and Anger" in the educational journal Virginia English Bulletin presents a plan for teaching adolescents this story along with James Baldwins "Sonnys Blues," again asserting the value of this text in the classroom.
Perhaps it is that classroom accessibility that has also made this story a testing area for theorists. In 1966, John Russell and Richard Ohmann uses the storys final sentence a sentence responsible for a number of articles as a reference point in a debate over what kinds of meaning can be found in a grammatical analysis of any text. One can contrast this with Anne Highams "An Aspect of Style in Araby," a theoretical piece which argues that the narrators grammar informs the readers perception of the story. The former article is abstract literary criticism, and the later is applied literary criticism.
As one can see the beginnings of a theoretical debate in the argument between Stone and apRoberts, "Araby" has since been used as the locus for literary debate. Wayne Booth argues from apRobertss perspective as he lashes out against "intellectual responsibility" and "pseudo-critics" in "Pluralism and its Rival." After a few pages of lashing out against the swelling post-structural tide, he turns to a reading of "Araby." He argues that "there is a hard resistant core of fact about Araby that will test what anyone wants to say about it," in opposition to the "complete skeptic or relativist [who] will say that what Araby seems to be it in fact is" (134-5). He further argues against relative meanings by mining this "commonsensical core of fact" and applying these to different approaches to literature (146). Booths point is that there will always be different readings to stories depending on how one approaches it, but one cannot deconstruct some essential facts at the heart of every story. Dogmatism is just as undesirable as total skepticism for Booth, and this article finds a happy medium between them. While Booths argument here could have applied to any story, he also manages to insightfully, if briefly, read the text through various techniques. Even though his goal is to properly harness post-structural criticism for college readers everywhere, he stumbles into a fairly interesting reading of the story itself.
"Araby" proved to be a fruitful training ground in a larger pedagogical project ten years after Booth. The Spring 1981 James Joyce Quarterly devoted a substantial portion of its space to the MURGE project, a collection of Miami University scholars who wanted to test a practical application of a story to Seymour Chatmans book Story and Discourse. The project consisted of an article, "Analyzing Araby as Story and Discourse" which contained the actual test, and several other articles which commented on the findings and the feasibility of Chatmans ideas. The central article seems to take Booths "commonsensical core" and break it down to minute parts; a comparison to Roland Barthess S/Z is not unfair. The MURGE people isolate 27 plot-significant events; they isolate the sentence at which point the action in the story begins (the "story-now") as well as several other "temporal sequences" in the book. They identify two main characters in the narrator and the boy protagonist and list three traits of the former and twelve of the latter. Similarly, it analyses various aspects of the narrative, such as the point-of-view and narrative expression. Throughout, the article makes a point of describing, not interpreting, the text. The final section comes closest to an interpretation, as it argues against Freimarcks and Mandels attempts to locate the story as a type of quest. All of this material is useful to a study of "Araby," although one would be correct in questioning the objectivity of every aspect of the project. Of course, the most important work of MURGE is not found here, but in the other articles reporting on their finding. In these, "Araby" is not a concern, and it takes a background to debate on Story and Discourse. However, the entire MURGE project illustrates the pedagogical use of "Araby," and, in a least one of the MURGE articles, how such a use can possibly illuminate the text.
In summary, there have been three main threads in "Araby" criticism since the early 1960s. The symbolic dominates, as critics have continued to find coded meanings in the storys objects, characters, and plot. The theoretical has yet to really test this story, but there is little doubt that these post-structural techniques will account for some illuminating articles in the future. And the pedagogical approach has found "Araby" both a teaching ground for students and an accessible starting point for more complex theoretical endeavors. While these threads do overlap on occasion, they have all independently provided innovative approaches to "Araby."
apRoberts, Robert P. "'Araby' and the Palimpsest of Criticism." The Antioch Review 26 (1967): 469-489.
A stern rebuttal to Harry Stones article, apRoberts attacks the Academys reliance on interpreting stories using arcane symbolism that the average reader would not immediately discern. He defends the priest against Stone's accusation of corruption: apRoberts suggests the priests reading material is much more innocuous than Stone implies (and that Stones suggested author of The Devout Commandment is incorrect), and Stones questioning of the priests charity is not grounded in the text. The boys florin is coin money and symbolic of nothing more, again in opposition to Stone. Mangans sister is far from a harlot, and "Mangan"a common Irish nameneed not refer to James Clarence Mangan. Stone is incorrect in his assertion that the boys "anguish and anger" are emotionally out of proportion of the storys events. Joyces details massively build the boys anticipation and lead to a similarly massive let-down.
Atherton, James S. "'Araby.'" In James Joyce's Dubliners. Clive Hart (ed.) London: Faber, 1969. 39-47.
"Story's autobiographical elements and precise, symbolic style." (From James Joyce: A Guide to Research by Rice)
Baechler, Leah. "Voices of Unexpected Lyricism in Two Dubliners Stories." James Joyce Quarterly 28:2 (Winter 1991): 361-276.
Focuses on the "non-narrative figurations" in "Araby" and "A Little Cloud." Using the example of a stage production of "Araby," Baechler illustrates how the multitude of voices from secondary characterssilence and ellipses, as well as wordscharacterize the boy and give nuance to this Realistic story. Examining the texts heteroglassia, one sees parallels between characters (priest/uncle; aunt/Mangans sister). A heteroglassic reading demonstrates that some of the story's scenes represent different perspectives of similar events recorded by different voices (e.g., the parallel between the boys meeting with Mangans sister on the steps and the girl at the bazaar.)
Barisonzi, Judith. "Who Eats Pig Cheeks?: Food and Class in 'Araby.'" James Joyce Quarterly 28:2 (Winter 1991): 518-19.
Building upon Walzl's article on the significance of "pigs cheeks" in "Araby," Barisonzi finds evidence that pigs cheeks were a dietary staple of poor Irishmen. When the narrator spots the delicacy at the market, it reifies his "snobbish, petit-bourgeois perception" of the place as coarse and squalid.
Barta, Peter I. "Munkacsy's Ecce Homo and Joyce's 'Araby.'" The New Hungarian Quarterly 31:118 (1990 Summer) 134-137.
No abstract available.
Beck, Warren. Joyce's "Dubliners": Substance, Vision, and Art. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1969.
A basic exegesis of "Araby" as a story of romantic disillusionment, with some emphasis on possible autobiographical elements.
Benstock, Bernard. "Arabesques: Third Position of Concord." James Joyce Quarterly 5:1 (Fall 1967): 30-39.
"Comments on the interpretive problems in the story, epitomized in the controversy between apRoberts and Stone." (From James Joyce: A Guide to Research by Rice)
Blythe, Hal and Charlie Sweet. "Diptych in 'Araby': The Key to Understanding the Boy's 'Anguish and Anger.'" Notes on Modern Irish Literature 6 (1994): 16-18.
No abstract available.
Booth, Wayne C. "Pluralism and Its Rivals." In Now Don't Try to Reason with Me. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1970. 131-49.
Concerned with the growing number of "pseudocritics" in the academy, Booth advocates an intellectual pluralism that can absorb different fields of critical study without entirely dismantling the text. Using "Araby" as a model, he discerns a "commonsensical core of fact"the events that occur in the story. He then looks at these facts through Aristotelian, Platonic, Nietzchian, and Freudian perspectives, with varying degrees of sincerity.
Brooks, Cleanth and Robert Penn Warren. "Discussion [of 'Araby']." In Understanding Fiction. Brooks and Warren (eds.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1979.
A very basic student-oriented precise and interpretation of "Araby." The article touches upon how the storys casual events have great significance, the narrators confusion of religious and romantic love, and the question of the narrators age and perspective. Discussion questions follow.
Brugaletta, John J. and Mary H. Hayden. "The Motivation for Anguish in Joyce's 'Araby.'" Studies in Short Fiction 15 (1978): 11-17.
Argues that Mangans Sister exists only as a created figment of the boys imagination. Mangans Sister should be older than the boy, yet her words to him seem oddly, unrealistically nervous, suggesting that the boy has created the scene. The time scheme of the story does not coincide with details. Other youthful Joycean narrators visualize non-existent persons, setting a precedent for "Araby." Ultimately, his vision of Mangans Sister fades when it is blended with the woman at the bazaar. Despite what some critics have argued, the boys anguish at the end is perfectly appropriate to the dismantling of his fantasy.
Burto, William. "Joyce's 'Araby.'" Explicator 25 (1967): Item 67.
A brief note on the symbolic significance of the boys failure to find a sixpenny entrance to the bazaar. Burto argues that such entrances are for children, and his ultimately entering the Schilling turnstile symbolizes the boys progression to maturity and manhood.
Chatman, Seymour. "Analgorithm." James Joyce Quarterly 18:3 (1981 Spring): 292-299.
See Sosnoskis "The MURGE Project" below.
Collins, Ben L. "Joyce's 'Araby' and the 'Extended Simile.'" James Joyce Quarterly 4 (1967): 84-90.
An "extended simile"Collinss coinageis a figure that links one item to another without equating them, and drawing numerous comparisons from them. Two such similes govern "Araby": the "wild garden," which, with its apple tree and bicycle pump, is likened to the Garden of Eden, but ultimately illustrates themes of love, religion, and paralysis. Mangans Sister is the focal simile; her name comes from the poet James Clarence Mangan, but she is alternately, momentarily compared to Dantes Beatrica and Helen of Troy.
Coulthard, A.R. "Joyce's 'Araby.'" Explicator 52:2 (1994 Winter): 97-99.
No abstract available.
Cronin, Edward J. "James Joyce's Trilogy and Epilogue: 'The Sisters,' 'An Encounter,' 'Araby,' and 'The Dead.'" Renascence: Essays on Value in Literature 31 (1979): 229-48.
The first three "tales of childhood" that constitute Dubliners involve youthful protagonists who learn something. The lessons of these stories are reinforced in "The Dead." In "Araby," the boy is characterized similarly to the characters of the earlier tales. As in the earlier tales, the boy is fascinated by abstractions. When faced with a very real feeling for Mangan's Sister, his "foolish blood" and inability to separate reality from illusion lead to his downfall. Fictional images of himself and others are gradually undone in the story. There is no evidence that his disillusionment is the catalyst for a loss of religious faith. However, the boy posits himself as God by creating his fictions, and he also becomes the worshipper of his own creation. As this paradigm leaves him with nothing at the end, it is this mock-religious faith that is shattered.
Culler, Jonathan. "The Application of Theory." James Joyce Quarterly 18:3 (1981 Spring): 287-292.
See Sosnoskis "The MURGE Project" below.
Dilworth, Thomas. "Yeats's Argument with Joyce in 'Ego Dominus Tuus.'" Review of English Studies: A Quarterly Journal of English Literature and the English Language 42:166 (1991 May): 232-34.
Yeats poem "Ego Dominus Tuus" disagrees with the Romantic disillusionment of "Araby." Verbal allusions and the Arabesque setting of the poem refer to the story. However, Yeatss poem suggests that idealism need not be self-deception, which is an idea that contrasts the boys epiphany in "Araby."
Doloff, Stephen. "Aspects of Milton's Paradise Lost in James Joyce's 'Araby.'" James Joyce Quarterly 33:1 (1995 Fall): 113-15.
The word "Arabie" appears in a Edenic allusion in Paradise Lost. The storys final sentence alludes to Paradise Losts Belial, and contrasts the vanity of the fallen angels with the narrators own vain defeat. The bazaars hall refers to the hall of Satans council, and the self-deceptive acceptance of defeat in Belials final speech. Echoes Joyces similar attitude towards his "fallen" Dubliners.
Doloff, Steven. "On the Road with Loyola: St. Ignatius' Pilgrimage as Model for James Joyce's 'Araby.'" James Joyce Quarterly 28:2 (1991 Winter): 515-17.
The narrative of "Araby" alludes to the religious conversion and Pilgrimage of St. Ignatius Loyola. The narrator discusses his romantic pursuit of Mangans Sister in religious terms, while Loyola in his Testament discusses his religious pilgrimage in chivalric language. Both experiences end in failure, with the bazaars eminent closing paralleling Loyolas expulsion from Jerusalem. However, Loyola ultimately triumphs when he founds the Jesuits, while the boy has no such subsequent triumph. The Loyola allusion, then, furthers the storys motif of disillusionment.
Doloff, Steven. "Rousseau and the Confessions of 'Araby.'" James Joyce Quarterly 33:2 (1996 Winter): 255-58.
As "Araby" parallels St. Ignatius Loyolas biography, it also echoes Rousseaus Confessions. Both Rousseau and Joyces narrators live with their aunt and uncle, and each speak of an early elder love in chivalric terms. Their literary passions parallel, as do their self-conscious shame of their sexual desires.
Egan, Joseph J. "Romantic Ireland, Dead and Gone: Joyce's 'Araby' as National Myth." Colby Library Quarterly 15 (1979): 188-93.
No abstract available.
Elbarbary, Samir. "The Theme of Idealised Love in 'Araby.'" Journal of English 15 (1987 Sept): 58-67.
No abstract available.
Flynn, Elizabeth A. Gender and Reading. Flynn, Elizabeth A. (ed.); Schweickart, Patrocinio P. (ed.). Gender and Reading: Essays on Readers, Texts, and Contexts. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP, 1986.
An article on gendered reading, using "Araby" as a model. The emphasis is on the nature of reading rather than literary analysis.
Freimarck, John. "'Araby': A Quest for Meaning." James Joyce Quarterly 7 (1970): 366-68.
There are echoes of the "Grail Quest story pattern" in "Araby." The storys title, the quest and marriage theme, and the bazaar setting all allude to the Grail. However, the boys voyeurism and his failure to give the proper answer to the female jar-seller illustrate that, unlike the Medieval Knight, he is unprepared for his journey and doomed to failure.
Friedman, Stanley. "Joyce's 'Araby.'" Explicator 24 (1966): Item 43.
The allusion to "The Arabs Farewell to his Steed" is meant to contrast the poems sentimentality with the disillusionment of "Araby." The Arabs willingness to accept seeing his departed horse only in his dreams mirrors the boys farewell to his romantic illusions.
Fuller, James A. "A Note on Joyces Araby." CEA Critic 20 (February 1958): 8.
No abstract available.
Garrison, Joseph M., Jr. "The Adult Consciousness of the Narrator in Joyce's 'Araby.'" Studies in Short Fiction 10 (1973): 416-17.
Commentators have often failed to note that Joyces narrator is an adult who brings a mature perspective to the storys events. Ultimately, "Araby" is not about the narrators romantic disenchantment, but his ability to intellectually appreciate beauty. Contrasting the indiscriminate observations of the young boy with the objectivity of the adult writer, the narrator discovers the distinction between fantasy and imagination.
Going, William T. "Joyce's 'Araby.'" Explicator 26 (1968): Item 39.
Building upon Friedmans note on "The Arabs Farewell to his Steed," Going suggests that the poem illustrates the middlebrow, tacky reading tastes of the uncle. Joyce uses literary allusions to build characterizations throughout his work. The uncles sentimental taste, then, reveals his intellectual paralysis.
Hahn, H. George. "Tarsicius: A Hagiographical Allusion in Joyce's 'Araby.'" Papers on Language and Literature: A Journal for Scholars and Critics of Language and Literature 27:3 (1991 Summer): 381-85.
Another reading of St. Tarsicius as it applies to "Araby." Joyces schooling would have familiarized him with the saint. In Portrait, Stephen Daedalus compares himself to St. Stephen, who is a saint associated with Tarsicius. The boy, like Tarsicius, is presented as an orphan, and both tales end in a sacrifice.
Harty, John. "Joyce's 'The Dead.'" Explicator 47:3 (1989 Spring): 35-37.
The word "fib" occurs in "Araby" and "The Dead," and is it essential to epiphanies in each tale. DArcys fib in "The Dead" conceals (and reveals) his lack of self-confidence about his singing. The "fib" the boy hears at the fair is the catalyst for his disillusionment. For Joyce, lies often reveal hidden facts.
Hauge, Hans. "The Ambiguous Artistic Programme of 'Araby.'" Westarp, Karl-Heinz (ed.). Joyce Centenary Offshoots: James Joyce, 1882-1892. Aarhus, Denmark: Seklos, Dept. of Eng., Univ. of Aarhus, 1983. 47-52.
No abstract available.
Higham, Anne S. "An Aspect of Style in 'Araby.'" Language and Style: An International Journal 15:1 (1982 Winter): 15-22.
Noting the varying interpretations of "Araby," Higham suggests that the key to interpreting the story lies in its grammar and style. The narrator, when speaking in the first person with himself as subject, rarely uses a direct object, resulting in the impression of "objectless, disengaged activity." Secondary characters, however, often use a grammatical object. The narrator, then, is often the object of others actions. The narrator is controlled by naming abstractions and his own body as well. Personification intrudes the story, again representing forces that act upon the boy. The storys final sentence breaks the narrator into an "I as character" and the more experienced "I as narrator."
Ingersoll, Earl G. Engendered Trope in Joyce's Dubliners. Carbondale, IL: Southern Illinois University Press, 1996.
A Lacanian approach to the first three Dubliners stories. Relationship of the boy to the Priest is evidenced only in the Priests booksa mixture of religion and adventure, as is the story. The Priest, then, is a lack which anticipates the boys own "immersion in textuality." Joycean epiphany is a triumph via creating metaphor. When the Real of the darkened bazaar destroys the Imaginary Ideal of Mangans sister, the boy enters into the Symbolic realm of creating his own story. This triumph is illustrated by the narrators use of metaphor throughout "Araby."
Johnson, James D. "Joyce's 'Araby' and Romans VII and VIII." American Notes and Queries 13 (1974): 38-40.
"Araby" has thematic parallels to Romans VII and VIII. Romans warns against turning away from religion, turning towards the things of the flesh, and vanity, and there are all main themes in "Araby." The boys confusion of flesh and spirit, and his turning towards the Oriental, anti-Christian bazaar illustrates his failure to heed Romans. The storys last line refers specifically to Romans passage on vanity.
Lang, Frederick K. "Rite East of Joyce's 'Araby.'" Journal of Ritual Studies 1:2 (1987 Summer): 111-120.
During his time in Trieste, Joyce became familiar with the rituals of the Eastern Orthodox Church. These rituals are reflected in "Araby," the most Triestian of all his stories. The boys worship on Mangans Sister is emblematic of Eastern Icons. The building housing the bazaar architecturally resembles an Eastern Church. Joyce may be critiquing the Eastern Church as well as the Irish Catholic Church.
Leonard, Garry M. "The Question and the Quest: The Story of Mangan's Sister." Modern Fiction Studies 35:3 (1989 Autumn): 459-477.
A Lacanian analysis in which Leonard argues that Mangans Sisters frustrated desire to go to Araby propels the story. This desire is "Araby"s subject, as it is the lack into which the narrator creates a Romantic myth of himself. Central is the boys gazing upon Mangans Sister, after which she approaches him to speakthe object thus redirects the subjects gaze. By storys end, the boy has turned this gaze upon himself, replacing his Romantic myth with a less flattering picture. He reinterprets the Others gaze, then, as her disappointment with the failure of the "hero."
Lyons, John O. "James Joyce and Chaucer's Prioress." English Language Notes 2 (1964): 127-32.
"Parallels between 'Araby' and the 'Prioress' Tale' as stories of initiation." (From James Joyce: A Guide to Research by Rice)
Mandel, Jerome. "Medieval Romance and the Structure of 'Araby.'" James Joyce Quarterly 13 (1976): 234-37.
"Araby" follows the traditional structure of a medieval Romance: the enfance, or description of the boys youth; the introduction of the lady; the commitment to a quest; and the quest itself. However, unlike its Medieval analogues, the boy apparently fails his quest. However, the adult narrator may be suggesting that the boys epiphany constitutes a successful conclusion.
Mandel, Jerome. "The Structure of 'Araby.'" Modern Language Studies 15:4 (1985 Fall): 48-54.
A slightly revised version of his James Joyce Quarterly (see above) article.
Morrisey, L. J. "Joyce's Narrative Strategies in 'Araby.'" Modern Fiction Studies 28:1 (1982 Spring): 45-52.
"Araby"s strength lies in the narrator. Combining first and third person narratives illustrates the boys maturity; he gradually steps forward to tell his own tale. Joyce utilizes three "moods" of the narrator: the simple naif, the romantic, and the harsh, judging adult. The first two moods are very distinguishable, but never quite separated. The third voice acts as critical commentary on the first two.
Morse, Donald E. "'Sing Three Songs of Araby': Theme and Allusion in Joyce's 'Araby.'" College Literature 5 (1978): 125-32.
No abstract available.
Norris, Margot. "Blind Streets and Seeing Houses: Araby's Dim Glass Revisited." Studies in Short Fiction 32:3 (1995 Summer): 309-18.
No abstract available.
Peters, Margot. "The Phonological Structure of James Joyce's 'Araby.'" Language and Style: An International Journal 6 (1973): 135-44.
"Thematic and structural significance of 'sound patterns' in the story." (From James Joyce: A Guide to Research by Rice)
Prince, Gerald. "What's the Story in Narratology?" James Joyce Quarterly 18:3 (1981 Spring): 277-285.
See Sosnoskis "The MURGE Project" below.
Robbins, Susan. "Anguish and Anger." Virginia English Bulletin 36:2 (1986 Winter): 59-61.
Compares "Araby" with James Baldwins "Sonnys Blues." Robbins concludes that both stories are useful for students to read because they each illustrate how anger and anguish can lead to a personal understanding of freedom.
Robinson, David W. "The Narration of Reading in Joyce's 'The Sisters,' 'An Encounter,' and 'Araby.'" Texas Studies in Literature and Language 29:4 (1987 Winter): 377-396.
The failures of Joyces protagonists in Dubliners is related to the failure of the readers to fully control the text. "Blindness" is a core concept in "Araby", and the narrator fails to interpret tangible events in light of his idealistic imagination. Such misinterpretation can be seen in critics attempts to decipher the Garden of Eden reference in the "wild garden." The attempts of commentators to compare the rusty bicycle pump to Satan are "ridiculous," and such is the point: "The pump deflates the allegorical afflatus which the combined hints about Eden have conjured in the mind of the reader."
Rosowski, Susan J. "Joyce's 'Araby' and Imaginative Freedom." Research Studies 44 (1976): 183-88.
"Boy merely adopts a 'new romantic role' at the story's end." (From James Joyce: A Guide to Research by Rice)
Russell, John and Richard Ohmann. "From Style to Meaning in 'Araby.'" College English 28 (1966): 170-171.
A rather technical linguistic debate using a sentence from "Araby." The focus is on the general issue of how much meaning one can find in sentence structure, rather than any interpretation of "Araby."
San Juan, Epifanio. James Joyce and the Craft of Fiction: An Interpretation of Dubliners. Cranbury, NJ: Associated University Presses, Inc., 1972.
A basic analysis of the structure of "Araby," focusing on how the storys organizational principles influence meaning. "Araby" begins with external detail and description, slowly moving into the interiority of the boy. Ultimately, the story is told on two levels: one of the events happening to the boy, another of the more experienced narrator. The boy fails to immediately understand the events that happen to him, but the narrator obliquely refers their meanings to the reader.
Senn, Fritz. "Naming in Dubliners (a first methermeneutic fumbling)" James Joyce Quarterly XX:XX (19XX): 465-8.
Senns discussion of some significant names in Dubliners contains a brief discussion of "Araby." The narrator is fascinated this the foreign word "araby" as spoken by Mangans sister, so much so that he never actually names his love-object. As with the initial two stories in Dubliners, names generally blur, rather than reveal identities.
Skau, Michael; Cassidy, Donald L. "Joyce's 'Araby.'" Explicator 35:2 (1976): 5-6.
Notes that the narrators comment, "I bore my chalice safely through a throng of foes," is an allusion to St. Tarsicius, a boy martyr entrusted with the sacrament and killed for refusing to give it to heathens. This allusion provides a spiritual analogue to the oft-noted Romantic characteristics of the narrator.
Sosnoski, James J. (director); Barney, Rick; Flavin, James; Hinrichs, Lois; Kelly, Rachel; McMaken, Ruth; Olubas, Paul; Russell, Tim; Uhlman, Diana. "Analyzing 'Araby' as Story and Discourse: A Summary of the MURGE Project." James Joyce Quarterly 18:3 (1981 Spring): 237-254.
A group project in which "Araby" is read through Seymour Chatman's Story & Discourse. A linguo-scientific reading, it begins by listing 27 core "kernal" sequences in the story, and proceeds into the story's temporal frame. There are only two characters -- the boy and the narrator -- who are distinctly characterized while the remaining characters function as part of the setting. Identifies 12 character traits of the boy, three of the narrator. Overview of the project is followed by four related articles by Jonathan Culler ("The Application of Theory"), Gerald Prince ("What's the Story in Narratology?"), and James J. Sosnoski ("STORY AND DISCOURSE and the Practice of Literary Criticism: 'Araby,' A Test Case" and "On the Anvil of Theoretical Debate: STORY AND DISCOURSE as Literary Theory"), and a final commentary by Chatman ("Analgorithm")."
Sosnoski, James J. "On the Anvil of Theoretical Debate: Story and Discourse as Literary Theory." James Joyce Quarterly 18:3 (1981 Spring): 267-276.
See Sosnoskis "The MURGE Project" above.
Sosnoski, James J. "Story and Discourse and the Practice of Literary Criticism: 'Araby,' a Test Case." James Joyce Quarterly 18:3 (1981 Spring): 255-265.
See Sosnoskis "The MURGE Project" above.
Stein, William B. "Joyce's 'Araby': Paradise Lost." Perspective 12 (1962): 215-22.
"Eden myth in the story." (From James Joyce: A Guide to Research by Rice)
Stone, Harry. "'Araby' and the Writings of James Joyce." The Antioch Review 25 (1965): 375-410.
A lengthy exegesis of the symbolism of "Araby" and the storys influence on Joyces later work. "Araby" is largely autobiography, as many of the storys details come from Joyces life. Joyce works other literary works into his tale, notably Yeatss The Celtic Twilight, DeQuinceys "Levana and Our Ladies of Sorrow," and James Clarence Mangans "Dark Rosaleen." The boys language of "anguish and anger" is too strong compared to the trivial events that cause them. Blindness and commercialism are dominating themes throughout "Araby." The boys longing for Mangans Sister anticipates Portraits Birdgirl episode and Ulysses' "Nausicaa." Mangans Sisterwho is, at the core, an Eve-like temptress-- is supposed to be "Dark Rosaleen." The boy sees in her both spirituality and commercialism, fatally confusing him. The fact that the bazaar is held in a church further conflates spirit and money. "Araby"s triumph is that it is a simple story that has many layers of meaning hidden in its symbolic structure.
Torchiana, Donald T. Backgrounds for Joyce's Dubliners. Boston: Allen & Unwin, 1986.
Obstientably an analysis of how the boys disillusionment stems from his discovery of himself and other characters as "double agents," the article focuses more on historical details. Notably, it gives a comprehensive history of the May 1894 Araby festival, and background on Francois Eugene Vidocq. Suggests that the girl at the storys end was Irish, and her contrast with the British boys suggests a English/Irish conflict.
Turaj, Frank. "'Araby' and Portrait: Stages of Pagan Conversion." English Language Notes 7 (1970): 209-13.
Stephen Dedaluss birdgirl epiphany in Portrait and "Araby" both illustrates a characters conversion from orthodox religion. Both stories use similar religious language and dark imagery, and each episode contains an epiphany inspired by a woman. However, "Araby"s narrator lacks Stephens intellectual awareness, the narrator cannot yet realize Stephens refusal to serve organized religion.
Wells, Walter. "John Updike's 'A & P': A Return Visit to Araby." Studies in Short Fiction 30:2 (1993 Spring): 127-33.
Joyces influence on Updike has often been noted, but little attention has been paid to the similarities between "A&P" and "Araby." Updikes protagonist, Sammy, becomes smitten with a lady in the supermarket. Later Joyces narrator, he becomes disoriented by the attraction. The physical characteristics of the desired female are similar, and both stories evoke Bunyans Vanity Fair for the climactic setting. Both protagonists make ultimately fruitless promises, but in Sammys case, his promise to quit the store has greater consequences. With its modern setting, Sammys epiphany is necessarily more ambivalent.
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES ON DUBLINERS
Attridge, Derek. The Cambridge Companion to James Joyce. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1990.
Baker, James R., and Thomas F. Staley, eds. James Joyce's "Dubliners": A Critical Handbook. Belmont: CA: Wadsworth, 1969.
Beck, Warren. Joyce's Dubliners: Substance, Vision, and Art. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1969.
Beja, Morris, ed. James Joyce: Dubliners and A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man. London: Macmillan, 1973.
Benstock, Bernard, ed. James Joyce: The Augmented Ninth. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, 1988.
Benstock, Bernard. Narrative Con/Texts in Dubliners. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1994.
Bidwell, Bruce, and Linda Heffer. The Joycean Way: A Topographic Guide to "Dubliners" & "A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man." Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1982.
Bloom, Harold, ed. James Joyce's Dubliners. Modern Critical Interpretations. New York: Chelsea House, 1988.
Bosinelli Bollettieri, Rosa Maria, and Harold Frederick Mosher. ReJoycing: New Readings of Dubliners. Irish Literature, History, and Culture. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, 1998.
Brandabur, Edward. A Scrupulous Meanness: A Study of Joyces Early Work. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1971.
Brown, Homer O. James Joyces Early Fiction: The Biography of a Form. Cleveland: Press of Case Western Reserve University, 1972.
Carey, Phyllis, and Ed Jewinski. Re--Joyce'n Beckett. New York: Fordham University Press, 1992.
Chace, William M. Joyce: A Collection of Critical Essays. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1974.
Daiches, David. The Novel and the Modern World. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1940.
Elmann, Richard. James Joyce. New York: Oxford University Press, 1959.
Elmann, Richard, ed. Letters of James Joyce, Volume II. New York: Viking Press: 1957.
Ellmann, Richard. Four Dubliners : Wilde, Yeats, Joyce, and Beckett. New York: G. Braziller, 1987.
Füger, Wilhelm, and James Joyce. Concordance to James Joyce's Dubliners: with a reverse index, a frequency list, and a conversion tab. Hildesheim, New York: Olms, 1980.
Gaiser, Gottlieb, ed. "Dubliners": International Perspectives on James Joyce. Troy, NY: Whitson, 1986.
Garrett, Peter K. Twentieth Century Interpretations of Dubliners. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1968.
Gifford, Don. Notes for Joyce: "Dubliners" and "A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man." New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1967. 2nd , rev. and enl. ed. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1982.
Gilbert, Stuart, ed. Letters of James Joyce. New York: Viking Press, 1957.
Goldman, Arnold. The Joyce Paradox: Form and Freedom in His Fiction. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1966.
Halper, Nathan. The Early James Joyce. New York: Columbia University Press, 1973.
Hart, Clive, ed. James Joyce's Dubliners: Critical Essays. London: Faber, 1969.
Heller, Vivian. Joyce, decadence, and emancipation. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1995.
Henke, Suzette A. James Joyce and the Politics of Desire. New York: Routledge, 1990.
Henke, Suzette A., and Elaine Unkeless. Women in Joyce. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1982.
Ingersoll, Earl G. Engendered Trope in Joyce's Dubliners. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 1996.
Leonard, Garry M. Reading "Dubliners" Again: A Lacanian Perspective. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, 1993.
MacCabe, Colin. James Joyce: New Perspectives. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 1982.
Magalener, Marvin. Time of Apprenticeship: The Fiction of Young James Joyce. New York: Abelard-Schuman, 1959.
Magalaner, Marvin and Richard M. Kain. Joyce: The Man, The Work, the Reputation. New York: New York University Press, 1956.
Pierce, David. James Joyce's Ireland. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1992.
Rice, Thomas Jackson. James Joyce: A Guide to Research. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc., 1982.
Rice, Thomas Jackson. Joyce, Chaos, and Complexity. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1997.
San Juan, Epifanio. James Joyce and the Craft of Fiction: An Interpretation of Dubliners. Cranbury, NJ: Associated University Presses, Inc., 1972.
Scholes, Robert and A. Walton Litz, eds. Dubliners: Text, Criticism and Notes. Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1976.
Scott, Bonnie Kime, ed. New Alliances in Joyce Studies. Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1988.
Staley, Thomas F., ed. James Joyce Today: Essays on the Major Works, commemorating the twenty-fifth anniversary of his death. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1966.
Tindall, William York. A Readers Guide to James Joyce. New York: Noonday Press, 1959.
Torchiana, Donald T. Backgrounds for Joyce's Dubliners. Boston: Allen & Unwin, 1986.
Wales, Katie. The Language of James Joyce. The Language of Literature. New York: St. Martin's Press, 1992.
Werner, Craig Hansen. Dubliners: A Pluralistic World. Boston, MA: Twayne Publishers, 1988.
JOURNAL ARTICLES AND CHAPTERS IN BOOKS
Adicks, Richard. "The Unconsecrated Eucharist in Dubliners." Studies in Short Fiction 5 (1968): 295-296.
Atherton, James S. "The Joyce of Dubliners." Staley, Thomas F. (ed.). James Joyce Today: Essays on the Major Works. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1966.
Baechler, Lea. "Voices of Unexpected Lyricism in Two Dubliners Stories." James Joyce Quarterly 28:2 (1991 Winter): 361-76.
Beckson, Karl. "Moore's The Untilled Field and Joyce's Dubliners: The Short Story's Intricate Maze." English Literature in Transition (1880-1920) 15: (1972): 291-304.
Beja, Morris. "One Good Look at Themselves: Epiphanies in Dubliners." In Work in Progress, edited by R. F. Peterson, Alan M. Kohn, and Edmund L. Epstein. Carbondale: University of Southern Illinois Press, 1983.
Benstock, Bernard. "Dubliners: Double Binds (the Constraints of Childhood and Youth)." Bosinelli, Rose Maria Bollettieri (ed.); Vaglio, C. Marengo (ed.); Boheemen, Chr. van (ed.). The Languages of Joyce: Selected Papers from the 11th International James Joyce Symposium, Venice, 12-18 June 1988. Philadelphia: Benjamins, 1992. pp.: 155-71.
Benstock, Bernard. "Narrative Strategies: Tellers in Dubliners Tales." Journal of Modern Literature 15:4 (1989 Spring): 541-559.
Benstock, Bernard. "The Gnomonics of Dubliners." MFS: Modern Fiction Studies 34:4 (1988 Winter): 519-539.
Benstock, Shari. "City Spaces and Women's Places in Joyce's Dublin." Proceedings of Ninth International James Joyce Symposium, Frankfurt, 1984. Benstock, Bernard (ed.). James Joyce: The Augmented Ninth. Syracuse: Syracuse UP, 1988. xi, 369 pp.: 293-307.
Bowen, Zack. "Joyce and the Epiphany Concept: A New Approach." Journal of Modern Literature 9:1 (1981-1982): 103-114.
Bramsback, Birgit. "James Joyce and the Divided Irish Cultural Heritage: Glimpses from Dubliners and A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man." Bramsback, Birgit (ed.). Homage to Ireland: Aspects of Culture, Literature and Language. Uppsala: Univ. Uppsala, 1990.
Carrier, Warren. "Dubliners: Joyce's Dantean Vision." Renascence: Essays on Value in Literature 17 (1965): 211-215.
Chatman, Seymour. "New Ways of Analyzing Narrative Structure, with an Example from Joyce's Dubliners." Language and Style: An International Journal 2 (1969): 3-36.
Chaudhry-Fryer, Mamta. "Power Play: Games in Joyce's Dubliners." Studies in Short Fiction 32:3 (1995 Summer): 319-27.
Chesnutt, Margaret. "Joyces's Dubliners: History, Ideology, and Social Reality." Eire-Ireland: A Journal of Irish 14:2 (1979): 93-105.
Church, Margaret. "Dubliners and Vico." James Joyce Quarterly 5 (1968): 150-156.
Conboy, Sheila C. "Exhibition and Inhibition: The Body Scene in Dubliners." Twentieth Century Literature: A Scholarly and Critical Journal 37:4 (1991 Winter): 405-19.
Cooke, M. G. "From Comedy to Terror: On Dubliners and the Development of Tone and Structure in the Modern Short Story." Massachusetts Review: A Quarterly of Literature, the Arts and Public Affairs 9 (1968): 331-343.
Cope, Jackson I. "An Epigraph for Dubliners." James Joyce Quarterly 7 (1970): 362-64.
Davis, Joseph K. "The City as Radical Order: James Joyce's Dubliners." Studies in the Literary Imagination 3:2 (1970): 79-96.
Delany, Paul; LeRoy, Gaylord C. "Joyce's Political Development and the Aesthetic of Dubliners." College English 34 (1972): 256-66.
Delany, Paul. "Joyce: Political Development and the Aesthetic of Dubliners." In The Artist and Political Vision. Ed. Benjamin R. Barber and Michael J. Gargas McGrath. New Brunswick: Transaction Books, 1982, pp. 221-31.
Doherty, Gerald. "Undercover Stories: Hypodiegetic narration in James Joyce's Dubliners." Journal of Narrative Technique 22:1 (1992 Winter): 35-47.
Dolan, T. P. "The Language of Dubliners." Martin, Augustine (ed.). James Joyce: The Artist and the Labyrinth. London: Ryan, 1990. 25-40.
Duffy, Edward. "'The Sisters' as an Introduction to Dubliners." Papers on Language and Literature: A Journal for Scholars and Critics of Language and Literature 22:4 (1986 Fall): 417-428.
Ehrlich, Heyward. "Socialism, Gender, and Imagery in Dubliners." Wawrzycka, Jolanta W. (ed.); Corcoran, Marlena G. (ed.); Norris, Margot (introd.). Gender in Joyce. Gainesville, FL: UP of Florida, 1997. 82-100.
Engel, Monroe. "Dubliners and Erotic Expectation." Brower, Reuben A. Twentieth-Century Literature in Retrospect. Cambridge: Harvard U.P, 1971. 3-26.
Faherty, Michael. "Heads and Tails: Rhetoric and Realism in Dubliners." James Joyce Quarterly 28:2 (1991 Winter): 377-85.
Fairhall, James. "Joyce's Dubliners." Explicator 43:2 (1985 Winter): 28-30.
Fairhall, James. "Joyce's Dubliners." Explicator 45:1 (1986 Fall): 32-34.
Fischer, Andreas. "Context-Free and Context-Sensitive Literature: Sherwood Anderson's Winesburg, Ohio and James Joyce's Dubliners." Forsyth, Neil (ed.). Reading Contexts. Tubingen: Narr, 1988. 13-31.
French, Marilyn. "Missing Pieces in Joyce's Dubliners." Twentieth Century Literature: A Scholarly and Critical Journal 24 (1978): 443-72.
Friedrich, Gerhard. "The Perspective of Joyce's Dubliners." College English, vol. 26 (1965), pp. 421-26.
Garrison, Joseph M. "Dubliners: Portraits of the Artist as a Narrator." Novel, vol. 8, 1975. Pp. 226-40.
Ghiselin, Brewster. "The Unity of Joyce's Dubliners." Accent, vol. 16 (1956), pp. 75-88 (Spring), 196-213 (Summer).
Gibbons, T. H. "Dubliners and the Critics," Critical Quarterly, IX (Summer, 1967), 179-87.
Henke, Suzette A. "Through a Cracked Looking-glass: Sex-role Stereotypes in Dubliners." In International Perspectives on James Joyce, edited by Gottlieb Gaiser. Troy, NY: Whitston, 1986.
Jones, David E. "Approaches to Dubliners: Joyce's." James Joyce Quarterly 15 (1978): 108-17.
Friedrich, Gerhard. The Perspective of Joyce's Dubliners." College English 26 (1965): 421-426.
Fuger, Wilhelm. "Crosslocution in Dubliners." James Joyce Quarterly 27:1 (1989 Fall): 87-99.
Garrison, Joseph M., Jr. "Dubliners: Portraits of the Artist as a Narrator." Novel: A Forum on Fiction 8 (1975): 226-40.
Gelfant, Blanche. "A Frame of Her Own: Joyce's Women in Dubliners Re-Viewed: Introduction." Proc. of Ninth Internat. James Joyce Symposium, Frankfurt, 1984. Benstock, Bernard (ed.). James Joyce: The Augmented Ninth. Syracuse: Syracuse UP, 1988. 263-266.
Gibbons, T. H. "Dubliners and the Critics." Critical Quarterly 9 (1967): 179-187.
Gillespie, Michael Patrick. "Aesthetic Evolution: The Shaping Forces behind Dubliners." Language and Style: An International Journal 19:2 (1986 Spring): 149-163.
Going, William T. "America in Joyce's Dubliners." Ball State University Forum 17:4 (1976): 46-49.
Gottfried, Ray. "'Scrupulous Meanness' Reconsidered: Dubliners as Stylistic Parody." Cheng, Vincent J. (ed.); Martin, Timothy (ed.). Joyce in Context. Cambridge, Eng.: Cambridge UP, 1992. 153-69.
Greyer, Grattan. "A Reader's Report on Dubliners." James Joyce Quarterly 10 (1973): 455-57.
Guerra, Lia. "Fragmentation in Dubliners and the Reader's Epiphany." Bosinelli, Rosa Maria (ed.); Pugliatti, Paola (ed.); Zacchi, Romana (ed.); Kemeny, Tomaso (introd.). Myriadminded Man: Jottings on Joyce. Bologna: Cooperativa Lib. Univ. Ed. Bologna: 1986. 41-49.
Haas, Robert. "Music in Dubliners." Colby Quarterly 28:1 (1992 March): 19-33.
Halper, Nathan. "The Life Chronology of Dubliners (II)." James Joyce Quarterly 16 (1979): 473-77.
Harrington, John P. "Beckett, Joyce, and Irish Writing: The Example of Beckett's 'Dubliners' Stories." Carey, Phyllis (ed.); Jewinski, Ed (ed.). RE: Joyce 'n Beckett. New York: Fordham UP, 1992. 31-42.
Hart, Clive. James Joyce's Dubliners: Critical Essays. New York: Viking, 1969.
Henke, Suzette A. "Through a Cracked Looking-Glass; Sex-Role Stereotypes in Dubliners." Gaiser, Gottlieb (ed.). International Perspectives on James Joyce. Troy, NY: Whitston, 1986. 2-31.
Herring, Phillip F. "Dubliners: The Trials of Adolescence." Reynolds, Mary T. James. Joyce: A Collection of Critical Essays. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1993. 67-80.
Huang, Xiuqi. "Aesthetic Values of Joycean Epiphany: On Writing Techniques of Dubliners." Waiguoyu 6:76 (1991 Dec): 11-16, 45.
Ingersoll, Earl G. "The Seasons and Times of Dubliners." Notes on Modern Irish Literature 10 (1998): 30-33.
Ingersoll, Earl G. Engendered Trope in Joyce's Dubliners. Carbondale: Southern Illinois UP, 1996.
Jedynak, Stanley L. "Epiphany as Structure in Dubliners." Greyfriar: Siena Studies in Literature 12 (1971): 29-56.
Johnsen, William A. "Joyce's Dubliners and the Futility of Modernism." McCormack, W. J. (ed.); Stead, Alistair (ed.). James Joyce and Modern Literature. London: Routledge, 1982. 5-21.
Johnson, Greg. "Dreaming Lives: The Inner World of Joyce's Dubliners." Ball State University Forum 20:3 (1979): 36-43.
Jordan, Richard D. "The Trouble with Dubliners." Durham University Journal 39 (1977): 35-40.
Kane, Jean. "Imperial Pathologies: Medical Discourse and Drink in Dubliners' 'Grace.'" Literature and Medicine 14:2 (1995 Fall): 191-209.
Keen, William P. "The Rhetoric of Spatial Focus in Joyce's Dubliners." Studies in Short Fiction 16 (1979): 195-203.
Kenner, Hugh. Joyces Voices. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1978.
Kibodeaux, R. Bruce. "'Counterparts': Dubliners without End." James Joyce Quarterly 14 (1976): 87-92.
Lane, Gary. A Word Index to James Joyce's Dubliners. New York: Haskell House, 1972.
Leonard, Garry. "Power, Pornography, and the Problem of Pleasure: The Semerotics of Desire and Commodity Culture in Joyce." James Joyce Quarterly 30-31:4-1 (1993 Summer-Fall): 615-65.
Levin, Richard, and Charles Shattuck. "First Flight to Ithaca: A New Reading of Joyce's Dubliners," in James Joyce: Two Decades of Criticism, ed. Seon Givens, pp. 47-94.
Lyons, J. B. "Diseases in Dubliners: Tokens of Disaffection." Irish Renaissance Annual 2 (1981): 185-203.
Martin, Augustine. "Joyce's Narrative Strategies in the Central Stories of Dubliners." Westarp, Karl-Heinz (ed.). Joyce Centenary Offshoots: James Joyce, 1882-1892. Aarhus, Denmark: Seklos, Dept. of Eng., Univ. of Aarhus, 1983. 27-46.
McDermott, M. Hubert. "'Clay' and Cle in Dubliners." James Joyce Quarterly 20:2 (1983 Winter): 227-228.
McGahern, John. "Dubliners." Martin, Augustine
(ed.). James Joyce: The Artist and the
Labyrinth. London: Ryan, 1990. 63-72.
McGuiness, Arthur E. "The Ambience of Space in Joyce's Dubliners." Studies in Short Fiction 11 (1974): 343-51.
McNiff, John. "James Joyce's Dubliners: A Study of Stagnation and Entrapment." DLSU Dialogue 23:2 (1988): 29-43.
Murphy, M. W. "Darkness in Dubliners." Modern Fiction Studies 15:1 (1969): 97-104.
O'Hehir, Brendan. A Classical Lexicon for Finnegans Wake: A Glossary of the Greek and Latin in the Major Works of Joyce including Finnegans Wake, The Poems, Dubliners, Stephen Hero, A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, Exiles, and Ulysses. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1977.
O'Shea, Michael J. (ed. and introd.). "Special Dubliners Issue." Studies in Short Fiction 32:3 (1995 Summer).
Paige, Linda Rohrer. "James Joyce's Darkly Colored Portraits of 'Mother' in Dubliners." Studies in Short Fiction 32:3 (1995 Summer): 329-40.
Park, Seong Soo. "A Rhetoric Gripped in Paralysis: James Joyce's Narrative Strategies in Dubliners." The Journal of English Language and Literature 38:1 (1992 Spring): 71-89.
Pearce, Sandra Manoogian. "'Umbrellas Re-Covered': A Note Uncovering Joyce's Sign of Sterility in Dubliners, Exiles, and Ulysses." Colby Quarterly 33:3 (1997 Sept.): 201-08.
Peterson, Richard F. "Joyce's Use of Time in Dubliners." Ball State University Forum 14:1 (1973): 43-51.
Putzel, Steven. "Portraits of Paralysis: Stories by Joyce and Stephens." Colby Library Quarterly 20:4 (1984 Dec.): 199-205.
Rabate, Jean-Michel. "Silence in Dubliners." MacCabe, Colin (ed.). James Joyce: New Perspectives. Brighton, Eng.; Bloomington: Harvester; Indiana UP, 1982. 45-72.
Restuccia, Frances L.. "Molly in Furs: Deleuzean/Masochian Masochism in the Writing of James Joyce." Novel: A Forum on Fiction (Novel) 18:2 (1985 Winter): 101-116.
Reynolds, Mary T. "The Dantean Design of Joyce's Dubliners." Benstock, Bernard (ed.). The Seventh of Joyce. Bloomington; Brighton: Indiana UP; Harvester, 1982. 124-130.
Rice, Thomas Jackson. "Paradigm Lost: 'Grace' and the Arrangement of Dubliners." Studies in Short Fiction 32:3 (1995 Summer): 405-21.
Riquelme, John Paul. "Stephen Hero, Dubliners, and Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man: Styles of Realism and Fantasy." Attridge, Derek (ed.). The Cambridge Companion to James Joyce. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1990. 103-130.
Rose, Danis; O'Hanlon, John. "The Origin of Dubliners: A Source." Joyce Studies Annual 4 (1993 Summer): 178-84.
Ruggieri, Franca. "Forms of Silence in Dubliners." Bosinelli, Rosa Maria (ed.); Pugliatti, Paola (ed.); Zacchi, Romana (ed.); Kemeny, Tomaso (introd.). Myriadminded Man: Jottings on Joyce. Bologna: Cooperativa Lib. Univ. Ed. Bologna, 1986. 51-58.
Russell, John. "James Joyce's Sentences (Dubliners)." Style 6 (1972): 260-93.
Scholes, Robert. "Further Observations on the Text of Dubliners." Studies in Bibliography: Papers of the Bibliographical Society of the University of Virginia 17 (1964): 107-122.
Scholes, Robert. "Some Observations on the Text of
Dubliners: 'The Dead.'"
Studies in Bibliography: Papers of the Bibliographical Society of the University of Virginia 15 (1962): 191-205.
Senn, Fritz. "Naming in Dubliners (a First Methermeneutic Fumbling)." James Joyce Quarterly 24:4 (1987 Summer): 465-468.
Sisson, Annette. "Constructing the Human Conscience in Joyce's Dubliners." Midwest Quarterly: A Journal of Contemporary Thought 30:4 (1989 Summer): 492-514.
Somerville, Jane. "Money in Dubliners." Studies in Short Fiction 12 (1975): 109-16.
Spoo, Robert E. "'Una piccola nuvoletta': Ferrero's Young Europe and Joyce's Mature Dubliners Stories." James Joyce Quarterly 24:4 (1987 Summer): 401-411.
Torchiana, Donald T. "James Joyce's Method in Dubliners." Rafroidi, Patrick; Brown, Terence. The Irish Short Story. Lille: Pubs de l'Univ. de Lille III, Gerrards Cross, Eng.: Smythe; Atlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities, 1979. 127-40.
Torchiana, Donald T. "Joyce and Dublin." Harmon, Maurice (ed.). The Irish Writer and the City. Gerrards Cross, Buckinghamshire; Totowa, NJ: Smythe; Barnes & Noble, 1984. 52-64.
Torchiana, Donald T. "The Opening of Dubliners: A Reconsideration." Irish University Review: A Journal of Irish Studies 1:2 (1971): 149-60.
Tysdahl, Bjorn J. "Odysseus in Dubliners: The Wine-Faced Farrington." James Joyce Quarterly 31:4 (1994 Summer): 549-52.
Valente, Joseph. "Joyce's Sexual Differnd: An Example from Dubliners." James Joyce Quarterly 28:2 (1991 Winter): 427-43.
Voelker, Joseph C. "'Chronicles of Disorder': Reading the Margins of Joyce's Dubliners." Colby Library Quarterly 18:2 (1982 June): 126-144.
Wachtel, Albert. "The Genesis of Constructive Self-Destruction in Joyce's Dubliners." Spectrum. 16 (1974): 79-86.
Walsh, Ruth M. "That Pervasive Mass. In Dubliners and A Portrait of The Artist As A Young Man." James Joyce Quarterly 8 (1971): 205-20.
Walzl, Florence L. "The Life Chronology of Dubliners." James Joyce Quarterly 14 (1977): 408-15.
West, Michael. "George Moore and the Hermeneutics of Joyce's Dubliners." Harvard Library Bulletin 26 (1978): 212-35.
Wigginton, B. Eliot. "Dubliners in Order." James Joyce Quarterly 7 (1970): 297-314.
Williams, Trevor L. "Resistance to Paralysis in Dubliners." MFS: Modern Fiction Studies 35:3 (1989 Autumn): 437-457.
Wirth-Nesher, Hana. "Reading Joyce's City: Public Space, Self, and Gender in Dubliners." Proc. of Ninth Internat. James Joyce Symposium, Frankfurt, 1984. Benstock, Bernard (ed.). James Joyce: The Augmented Ninth. Syracuse: Syracuse UP, 1988. 282-292.
Wright, David G. "Interactive Stories in Dubliners." Studies in Short Fiction 32:3 (1995 Summer): 285-93.
Brown, James Stewart. "Joyce's Doctrine of Denial: Families and Forgetting in 'Dubliners', 'A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man', and 'Ulysses.'" Dissertation Abstracts International 54:11 (1994) 4087A.
Dickler, Howard Cronson. "James Joyce's Ulysses: An Introduction to the Literature of Redemption." Dissertation Abstracts International 46:4 (1985 Oct.): 987A.
Gray, Paul Edward. "James Joyce's Dubliners: A Study of the Narrator's Role in Modern Fiction." Dissertation Abstracts International 26 (1966): 6042.
Heller, Daniela. "Everyman's Epiphany: Readings of James Joyce's Dubliners, A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man and Ulysses." Dissertation Abstracts International 48:10 (1988 April): 2634A-2635A.
Kelly, Joseph Patrick. "Joyce's Reputation and the Reception History of 'Dubliners.'" Dissertation Abstracts International 53:11 (1993 May): 3903A.
Kirchner, James Patrick. "Parody in the Fiction of James Joyce." Dissertation Abstracts International 57:11 (1997 May): 4736.
Lang, Frederick Karel. "The Joycean Liturgy: Religious Symbolism and Ritual from Dubliners through Ulysses." Dissertation Abstracts International 42:9 (1982 Mar.): 4007A-4008A.
Leonard, Garry Martin. "William Blake's 'Vegetable Existence' and James Joyce's 'Moral Paralysis': The Relationship between Blake's Romantic Philosophy and Joyce's Thematic Concerns in Dubliners and A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man." Dissertation Abstracts International 47:4 (1986 Oct.): 1319A.
Lohani, Shreedhar Prasad. "The Narrator in Fiction: A Study of the Narrator's Presence in Joyce's Dubliners and Hemingway's In Our Time." Dissertation Abstracts International 45:8 (1985 Feb): 2517A.
Maher, Raphael Alphonse Joseph. "'The Intellectual Imagination': A Study of Contrary Modes of Perception in Joyce's Dubliners, A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, Exiles and Ulysses." Dissertation Abstracts International 38 (1977).
Min, Taeun. "Subjectivity, Language, and Society in Joyce's 'Dubliners,' 'A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man,' and 'Ulysses.'" Dissertation Abstracts International 52:5 (1991 Nov): 1753A.
Owens, Coilin Don. "Dubliners and the Irish Tradition." Dissertation Abstracts International 36 (1975): 3698A-99A.
Schwartzman, Myron. "The Continuity of Joyce's Dubliners, A Portrait, and Ulysses." Dissertation Abstracts International 34 (1974): 5992A.
Slack, John S. "Games/Joyce: Literary and Cultural Aspects of Play from 'Dubliners' through 'Ulysses'." Dissertation Abstracts International 56:7 (1996 Jan): 2698A.
Toth, Alexander S., Jr. "Joyce-Bergson Correspondences in the Theory and Time Structure of Dubliners, A Portrait, and Ulysses." Dissertation Abstracts International 30 (1969): 738A-39A.
Zlotnick, Joan. "Dubliners in Winesburg, Ohio: A Note on Joyce's 'The Sisters' and Anderson's 'The Philosopher'." Studies in Short Fiction 12 (1975): 405-07.